The whole collab and this thread is really sad to look at. I would say pathetic but I am thinking about a word that is more hurtful.
Next time you should have a small poll giving out 3-5 different topics. The topic the most people vote for will be the next collab. That way you people avoid the lack of entries. I'm not sure if it's just me, but the whole MGS collab passed by really quickly with barely any attention brought to it. I can't really tell you guys how you could've brought up some more attention to it but still.
You should have written that you will reject every cardboard box and codec parts right from the beginning. No one would've made one of these then which would've been by far better. These 2 jokes are very overused and just not original and funny anymore.
Maybe talk to some good animators who might be interested before making the actual collab to make sure that there are some qualitative parts, too. Then again, NG has a lot of good animators and I doubt the staff would have the time to do this.
To the staff, I don't think that any of this, besides the theme picking, is your fault. It's the fault of the lazy NG stuff that has dumbed down within a year so much that barely any of them can come up with good ideas anymore. I haven't EVER played the game and could probably come up with a good idea for the collab just by knowing all the NG parodies of metal gear solid. Heck, all you need to do is watching the trailer or maybe a video review of the game. Just search for videos on Youtube, how hard can it be.
I think the majority of the people who joined this collaboration entered with cardboard box and codec jokes because they proved to be very successful in the past hundred of Metal Gear Solid submissions. They aren't even considering making an actual parody of the game, they are making parodies of parodies. But that's just my opinion.
Maybe some of them don't even remember what the game had to it. I for once know that there are more than 2 parts but all I ever see is the main character of the first game. I have seen my brother playing the second game with a main character called Raiden (Correct me if I'm wrong). It had a fat jerk on roller skates that planted bombs all over the game map. I haven't payed attention to what it was, a boat or something alike. It would be really easy to make fun of this Fatman or perhaps even the sniper from part 1, which I have also seen my brother defeat. It's not really that hard coming up with ideas based on characters. Using the same character (Snake in this case) over and over again gets tiring to see and results in overuse of jokes.
I feel like I am repeating towards the end of every paragraph. That should prove my point well enough though.
Sorry for the long post, you don't need to read it if you want your part to be shit and similar to all the other parts.