At 7/26/09 08:05 PM, loansindi wrote:
This system assumes that a large portion of the audio portal listeners will listen, and vote, during your 24 hour period. They'll be voting against any zero/fiving that has happened in the past six days. If a spam track has been upvoted and a good track has been downvoted, then it's going to be hard for those tracks to equalize and be 'fixed' in the course of one day, won't it?
You'd be surprised. You can see with a song like Autotune Flowers how quickly the score drops once it's hit the front page. That song hit #1 of the week this week with a score above 4.40, but within 12 hours the score was close to a 3.0. It's a good example of how quickly the community can show what they think of a song.
Some songs, yes, will have many votes and will be hard to change in that time period. However, most songs that make best of the week currently do so with only 20-40 votes, and such a small number of votes is what allows them to manipulate the score in the first place. Even though it is only 24 hours, with the entire portal voting each song could easily get over 200 votes in the voting period. Regardless of whether the author has 5 hack accounts or 50, there will simply be too many legitimate votes flooding in during that period to allow a crappy song to sustain a high score.
people who zerobomb themselves into recognition are getting paid for it
how much? I've spoken to artists who get large volumes of traffic, and not one of them has made any noticeable sum from their music.
Admittedly it's a small sum of money. However I'd still prefer to prevent them from having it if they didn't deserve it in the first place.
This problem will still be evident during some sort of last minute voting, because people using unscrupulous methods are, in my eyes, more likely to be ready to vote in that critical last day.
That is precisely my point, and the reason for this feature: with the Day of Judgment, zerobombing won't matter.
Imagine it like this: If there are only 30 votes on a song, and a guy comes along and uses hack accounts to give the song 5 zeroes, the score will drop immensely. This is what happens currently. However, if there are 150 votes on a song, and a guy comes along and zerobombs it, the 5 zeroes will have almost no effect, and the score will much more closely resemble what the 150 votes want it to be.
Cheat voting only works because so few people look at each individual song. Once you have hundreds of people looking at a song, zerobombing is nullified, for one or two zeros can no longer have the significant effect that it did.