Hey guys, this is an idea for the Audio Portal I've been thinking about for a while, and I was hoping for your opinions/criticisms of it:
This new feature would be called the Day of Judgment. The basic idea is that 24 hours before the Top 5 songs of the week are decided, the highest-ranking 15 songs of that week are put into a list, which is visible from the front page of the audio portal. These songs would ideally be some of the best songs submitted that week, and also some that are quite bad, and were merely zerobombed up there. During the next 24 hours, anyone can vote on any of the 15 songs. As this pool of music would be exposed to the entire community, the higher-caliber songs would stand out by the end of the voting period, and after 24 hours the 5 songs with the highest score would be given the 5 spots of Best of the Week. The following week, 24 hours before the next Top 5 are decided, the process would start over, ensuring that 5 new and quality songs take the previous ones' place.
What is the benefit of this feature? Firstly and most prominently, this feature would allow for the Top 5 of the Week to truly reflect what the audio community wants to hear. Currently, one can only get a spot on the Top 5 through sheer luck, or more often, zerobombing the hell out of everyone else's submissions. What this often creates is a set a five songs that nowhere near represents the quality of music that the Audio Portal can put out. You've all seen terrible songs on the best of the week, and felt that anger when you knew a more deserving song should have its place. The Day of Judgment would help to solve this problem. In the 24 hour voting period, it would be up to the community to decide which of the 15 songs of that week were worthy of being recognized, and which ones had no place being recognized at all. Naturally, people would find ways to cheat themselves onto the 15 spots, but with the eyes of the entire Audio Portal on them, their song would get voted down, and receive no Top 5 spot. After all, the only reason zero bombing is a problem is because individual songs generally do not get much attention, and their scores can be easily manipulated by just 1 or 2 zeroes. However, once the 15 songs that are being considered for Top 5 are shown to the whole of Newgrounds, there will be enough legitimate voting to negate any zerobombing that might continue. Essentially, this process would be a filter, ensuring that songs that have no place representing the Audio Portal are taken out of the running for the Top 5 positions.
A system along these lines is more important, I believe, now than ever, for with the introduction of the Ad Revenue system, people who zerobomb themselves into recognition are getting paid for it. With such monetary reward, there is now more and more incentive to cheat one's song into a spot on the Top 5. Hopefully, the Day of Judgment would nullify such cheating. No matter how hard people worked to get their undeserving song exposure, they would ultimately be stopped during the day of judgment, during which the Audio Community would ensure that their song would not be one of the 5 moving on.
An ideal scenario I imagine would be thus: The Day of Judgment begins, and the 15 highest scored songs of the week are put into the pool on the front page of the AP. One of them is an incredibly high-quality piece of music whose score was lower than it should be. Another is (just as an example, as its score is currently so low) Autotune Flowers, which only had such a high score due to zerobombing. Now, during the next 24 hours the entire Audio Portal would listen to both these songs, and Autotuned Flowers's score would slowly drop, as the high-quality piece's would rise. By the end of the 24 hours, the good song, assuming that it was indeed a song that the community respected and found worthy of exposure, would have a much higher score and be given one of the Top 5 spots, while Autotuned Flowers, it's score lowered, would receive none of the recognition that it tried to steal away from the better song. But again, just an example.
I think the Day of Judgment feature could be a great addition to the portal, and could ensure that what gets put on the Best of the Week truly is the best music of that week, and not merely a product of score manipulation. HOWEVER, I am not naive enough to believe that this idea is perfect, and I believe that it could use improvement and critique. So, now I ask you, what do you think of this idea? Would it a great addition, or only further muddle an already complicated system? I ask because I hope to make this idea into the best one it can be before submitting into the Audio Portal improvements thread, and I want to make sure it can stand up to any criticisms when that day comes. So criticize away
(Rucklo has given me permission to post this thread, and he would like to remind everyone that this is an exception to the normal rules, so don't go posting all your ideas and incurring his wrath on me)
Thanks for reading, tell me what you think