I posted a while back about the lack of original ideas in all those Mario sprite-based movies that flood the Portal on a daily basis. So I took a couple of hours of my time and came up with a pretty extensive list of ideas that could be used for Mario sprite movies.
I'm not a sprite animator, so I don't have any interest in animating any of these ideas. I just want to see some new and fresh Mario-related ideas in the Portal. So, go for it! Use any of these ideas as you wish. If anyone uses any of these, feel free to give me credit. :)
Any Mario Game:
Mario tries to throw a fireball but his hand catches on fire.
Mario jumps up to collect a star but the star stabs him in the face/head.
Mario tries to figure out how those question blocks float in the air.
Things Mario could throw other than fireballs: Beach balls, tennis balls, semen, water balls, a Slinky, ninja stars, Toad, darts, axes, feces, swastikas...
"Mirror, Mirror" Mario - An evil Mario with a goatee walks backwards through a left-scrolling level.
"One Life to Live" - Mario goes through a level and dies. But he doesn't come back to life. Bowser quickly takes over the Mushroom Kingdom, killing Luigi, enslaving the Toads and making the Princess his sex slave. The Mushroom Kingdom turns into a nightmarish wasteland - end of story.
Mario falls down a bottomless pit...
...and winds up in China.
...and keeps falling and falling until he wakes up in a cold sweat.
...and lands in the molten core of the earth.
...to commit suicide.
Mario falls down a bottomless pit, and discovers it isn't bottomless...
...while he's trapped down there, some Goombas come by and urinate on him.
...the pit fills with water until he drowns.
...Luigi comes by and fills the pit with dirt while laughing.
...it turns out to be the pit from Mortal Kombat, and Mario gets impaled.
Mario eats a mushroom and gets high. He gets the munchies and starts eating the bricks, the scenery, the enemies, even Toad's head (thinking he's another mushroom).
A bad player keeps killing Mario at the same spot in a level. Eventually, Mario gets pissed off and either yells at the player, or pops out of the screen and smacks him!
Mario stars in a remake of "It's A Wonderful Life", where a Boo Buddy ghost shows Mario what the Mushroom Kingdom would be like if he weren't around. In this world, Luigi is the hero who defeats all the enemies and gets to have wild monkey sex with the Princess. Mario goes, "Noooooo!!!!"
Mario's Ordinary Day - What does Mario do when he's not saving the Princess or kicking Koopa butt? He's laying underneath a pipe, holding a wrench, trying to unclog a toilet. It should be really boring and tedious, until (insert poop joke here).
NES - Super Mario Bros.
Mario approaches an area with a couple of bushes, and a shot rings out. Mario hits the dirt, and looks around to see who's shooting at him. It turns out to be a player with a light gun shooting at the ducks from Duck Hunt. Mario could stomp on the ducks, or get shot himself, or fight off the dog.
Mario vs. the timer countdown - where it goes under 100 and that little music cue comes up and the theme speeds up. Mario races to the end of the level before the time runs out, but...
...he trips and falls in a hole just prior to reaching the flagpole.
...Sonic the Hedgehog gets to the flagpole before him.
...he gets run over by an Excitebike guy.
Mario runs into an enemy and dies right there on the spot. Cut to the level screen. Mario goes through the level again, and walks past his dead body lying there.
Fire Mario encounters a Goomba, who hits a ? block and gets himself a mushroom. The Goomba hits another ? block and obtains a Fire Flower. Mario and the Goomba engage in a wicked battle with kick-ass techno music.
A Piranha plant falls in love with Mario, and keeps popping up in pipes everywhere, trying to kiss him.
You know how you can't beat the level until you touch the flagpole? What would happen if the flagpole screamed and ran away?
NES - Super Mario Bros. 2
Mario watches a Pidgit floating on a magic carpet and gets an idea (!) He jumps up, throws the Pidgit off, and starts flying away. Unfortunately, Mario and the carpet immediately plummet into a hole.
Mario picks up a key and sets off the Phanto. He puts it back, and the Phanto goes away. Repeat this ad nauseum until the Phanto gets pissed off.
Birdo shoots an egg at Mario. Mario swings a baseball bat, knocking the egg right back into Birdo's mouth. Birdo chokes on it and dies.
Other characters for the Character Select Screen?
Mario pulls up a piece of grass and...
...throws his back out.
...smokes it like weed.
...it's just the piece of grass. He throws it at an enemy, who just laughs at him.
Mario realizes that if you collect 5 cherries, you get an invincibility star. He collects four of them, but Pac-Man beats him to the last one.
One of Birdo's eggs hatches, and out comes a half-Birdo, half-Mario.
NES - Super Mario Bros. 3
After Bowser falls to his death, Mario finds the Princess in that little room at the end...except:
...he finds her corpse.
...he finds her with Luigi (!)
...he finds her with Bowser (!)(!)
...he finds her engaging in girl-on-girl action with Wendy O. Koopa. (o)(o)
...a flattened Bowser enters the room, wanting a rematch.
The sun chases after Mario and burns his ass.
Rejected Suit ideas:
Bat Suit (the 60s "Batman" theme plays)
Camel Suit, with humps on the back
Monkey Suit (throws flaming poo balls)
Ninja Turtle Suit, accompanied by the NES Ninja Turtles theme. Mario swings some nunchucks around.
Zoot Suit (complete with "Stayin' Alive" and disco balls)
Business Suit, with briefcase and sunglasses
Leather Chaps (add in Mario's voice going "Whoa!")
Star Trek Uniform (with photon torpedoes instead of fireballs)
Kirby Suit, Mario inhales a Goomba and chokes on it.
Luigi Suit - a naked Luigi chases after him, wanting his clothes back
Nazi SS Uniform (throwing swastikas)
Big Bertha eats Mario, then gets eaten by a Bigger Bertha, and a Bigger one, and so on...
Mario turns into a statue near a Hammer Brother. The Hammer Brother takes his hammer and smashes the statue!
A couple of Lakitus go fishing. One of them catches a tiny fish. The other one catches a medium-size fish, and the first one catches a Big Bertha, who (of course) eats them.
Game Boy - Super Mario Land 2
Mario puts on those gay bunny ears and flies away. Meanwhile, one of those adorable bunnies from Zelda: Link's Awakening is bleeding and screaming because Mario ripped his ears off.
Mario goes into space, and...
...an enemy knocks his helmet off. His head expands and explodes.
...he gets abducted by a UFO.
...he re-enacts the moon landing, complete with the "One small step for man..." audio.
SNES - Super Mario Kart
One of the racers gets pulled over by the cops, and winds up in jail (still in their kart).
While he races, Mario's kart falls apart a piece at a time. Eventually the whole frame falls apart, and Mario skids face-first into the pavement. Bloody!
Bowser ties Mario to his kart and pushes the kart into a lake. Mario dies a slow drowning death.
The kart racers get into a huge pile-up on the freeway.
The kart racers all have to stop in the middle of a race to let some baby ducks cross the way.
Mario takes his kart to a repair shop, where the the mechanic points out the problem - a Koopa shell stuck in the exhaust pipe.
Mario gets stuck behind the Princess, who is driving really slow. He does everything he can to get around her, and when he does, he eventually gives her the finger and speeds off.
Donkey Kong Jr. and Toad get into a fender-bender. They slowly get out and assess the damage. The other kart racers gawk at the accident scene as they slowly drive by. Things get even more awkward when Toad admits he's uninsured.