Newgrounds.com — Everything, By Everyone.

Checking login status…

USERNAME:

PASSWORD:

Logging in…

Logged in as:
.
Logging out…
Inbox My Account Log Out


Reviews For: Forest of the Unnamed

(6 Reviews • Avg: 8.83/10)

Sort by: [ date | rating ]

There is 1 page of reviews.


Score: 10
ductape723

"Souds like..."

date: April 18, 2008

Does not sound like anything Harry Potter but it totally sounds like the lind of musioc Danny Elfman would write. Still pretty cool.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
People aren't in agreement over whether this is helpful or not.

Score: 7
CircleNineStudios

"yes"

date: August 2, 2007

this reminds me of one of my favorite musicians: Danny Elfman. awesome

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 10
madboss

"Great!"

date: October 26, 2006

It's a really great track: well composed, variated structure and above that well instrumented. Great harp apperigator - I loved it.

The whole song brought a kind of Halloweenish feeling for me - a haunted house came to my mind for this one rather than a forest. Bot it's still a great piece and I think it's even better that you haven't used the full orchestra for this - it makes the feeling of the song more ... classical.

So great job! 5/5 from me!

Author's Response:

Danke! :D

Full orchestras can be overwhelming sometimes, I always like working small and adding as I go. If you compose for a smaller group of instruments, you get to know each instrument better and that helps a lot in orchestral composition.

But before I break down into lectures, thanks a ton for the review!

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 9
Esn

"Great instrumentation"

by: Esn
date: October 25, 2006

I just love the instrumentation in this piece - could I please know which instruments it was written for?

Every instrument was distinct, and it had a magical Nutcracker-opera-like feeling... kinda like the first snowfall.

This would make a great soundtrack for a game, and it also seems perfect for any Christmas flashes on Newgrounds that might want to use it - have you thought of entering that audio contest?

I don't have too much criticism, I'm afraid. I give a "9" because the piece simply isn't too ambitious - it's a little simple, but that's ok. It's great just the way it is.

P.S. Just a suggestion to avoid the confusion - instead of saying "this is a piece from x.com" say "this is a piece FOR x.com". I admit that even I wasn't sure what to think, until I saw your response to the guy below.

Author's Response:

Your absolutely right in your suggestion, the phrasing was very open to misinterpretation. My apologies about that. I reacted strongly to the review below, but on a certain level I maintain that to make such an accusation publicly one must delve deeper.

But with that aside, this was written for:
Glockenspiel
Harp (2)
Violin
Cello
Double bass
(all GPO)

Hmmm never thought about putting it in the MAC tho. For some reason I'm just not feeling particularly inspired to submit to the MAC.

Generally speaking this was a pretty idle piece, the phrases and dynamics work on a more microscopic scale, and the instrumentation is limited and not exploited fully. Nevertheless, what redeemed this piece in my eyes the most was its harmonic complexity in numerous parts (such as harp arpeggios on the third instance of the first melody). The harmonies were subtle touches when placed in this kind of dreamy, Nutcracker-y (as you mentioned) style, but always fun to experiment with.

Anyhoo, sorry about the tangents, thanks for the awesome review. :P

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 10
Slayer-of-trolls

"wow,"

date: October 25, 2006

This is kicks ass. Looks like I'm gonna have to start composing orchestral music again...

Author's Response:

Damn straight you will! >:(

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Score: 7
nerky

"uh...you said yourself it wasn't yours"

by: nerky
date: September 14, 2006

you said yourself that you just recorded it off of a site, that's the only reason for the low score

Author's Response:

Look, I know everyone's all like "oh noes! stolen audio everywhere!" but don't be a presumptuous idiot about it. Both this and Among the Ruins are original tracks by me written for the soundtrack of the game BoF Online.

Where did I say, "I did not compose this track"? I don't seem to recall every mentioning that.

So next time you want to make that accusation, try going about it a little more logically. In this case, that might include visiting the website. It becomes apparent immediately that it's a game. I've already stated that these are from the game soundtrack, so you might wonder, did Simon F. actually compose music for this game? So then, conveniently, there's a "Development Team" link on the left hand side. Well, what a shocker, there I am!

So, in summary, please think before you say something? It doesn't do honest artists any good if people are being idiots and making stupid assumptions based on loose interpretations that they take as a basis for factual evidence.

Rate this review:
Helpful!
Useless.
Flag as abusive.
No users have weighed in on this review.

Sort by: [ date | rating ]

There is 1 page of reviews.