Minute 0.00-2.00:
Great athmosphere. Somehow it reminds me of singing whales in the deep - everything is sounding quite hollow and interesting. Great sounddesign. Also the descrete use of synths for the melody worked very well.
Minute 2.00-4.50
Hm - in my opinion the break in athmosphere was to extreme - it ripped me out of the underwater - mood quite hard. Also it is a little bit repetitive here. I would vary the musical part here and invent a low volume introduction which leads out of the "underwater" part very smoothly. In the beginning of the new part i would let the synth ambiences stil dominate the scenery. While it could be reduced more and more the instrumental part could increase its presence and finally be focused. For the instruments here. I would recommend:
- add more reverb to the piano and use softer velocities
- work with the expression CC for the cello. This will make it much more vivid
- in this part the upper frequencies are quite empty. Maybe you stil could ad some thing here - a low volume high synth ambient with clackles and stuff - dont know. Maybe bowed glasses...
Afte a climax i would come back to the underwater ambience to close the circle in the end.
Overall a creative piece. The first part - in my ears - is flawless. Maybe you could make the 2 parts harmonize better with each other and adjust a few little things.
Good job. Keep it up!
4/5 (voted 5)