Jakobe V1 - Lol, nice intro. Fat diss is repetitive but dubstep line is strong. Didn't understand the breath control line, Richard seems fine to me.
Richard V1 - Sarcasm flip, fat flip is okay, shitty mic line is okay.
Jakobe V2 - Voting flip is incredibly strong. Rhyming fuck and luck is kind of lame. Pokemon line is smooth but more annoying fat disses.
Richard V2 - Voice diss is funny. Jigglypuff line is clever. Finisher is okay.
Overall Jakobe's fat disses brought him down a lot but Richard didn't bring enough to the table to contend with him even then. I'd give Jakobe the win. Both are great MCs though.