Be a Supporter!

Guitar Vs. Piano [ver. XCEED]

Download this song! Lights Expand Collapse

Credits & Info

Uploaded
Apr 30, 2010 | 11:59 AM EDT
File Info
Song
6 MB
4 min 19 sec
Score
4.37 / 5.00

Related Content

Heard in 2 Entries!


View all submissions featuring this audio file.

Licensing Terms

You may not use this work for commercial purposes without making specific arrangements with the artist UNLESS your work is a web-based game or animation, in which case you may use this freely.

Score:
Rated 4.37 / 5 stars
Plays & Downloads:
21,327 Plays | 2,428 Downloads
Share Links:
Genres:
Other - Miscellaneous
Tags:
None

Author Comments

Once upon a time in October 14, 2004, Goukisan created the masterpiece known today as Guitar Vs. Piano. In the same year, he created a sequel, but it wasn't as popular as the original. That caused him to make Guitar Vs. Piano 1.2, his most well-known piece from the Guitar Vs. Piano series to date and any Newgrounds user would obviously be living in a cave if he or she hasn't heard the song.

And then, April 28, 2009, I got around to asking Goukisan for permission to remix the song, which he agreed to giving. A year after, I restarted the remix and finished it after 4 days of continuous work!

Hope I gave the original justice, and hope you enjoy!

More Info & Download:
http://rtnario.wordpress.
com/2010/04/30/leaf-xceed -music-division-guitar-vs -piano-ver-xceed/
(remove spaces)

Reviews


MadenameXDMadenameXD

Rated 2.5 / 5 stars

Piano

The piano was a major part to this, and they had it loud for a reason. The reason I'm only giving a 5/10 and a 3/5 is because of a lack of half the main song. The song in parts focuses on the piano as an essence of putting the song together, but by making the piano much quieter, and covering a lot of things with drums, it's seeming repetitive of drums and guitar. If you aren't going to have the piano be its normal self, I personally would recommend just cutting that part out because it's tiny in the background with loud drums in front.


People find this review helpful!
rtnario responds:

Well, some valid points made about how you interpret the original. I guess you would've appreciated my original concept, where I'd have both a full band and a complete orchestra playing this remix. However, that's nowhere near as common as a simple band with keyboards XD I'd rather have five guitars and one keyboard instead of five keyboards and one guitar...to each his own o:

Thanks for the insightful review, though. Will seriously keep it in mind when I work on something like this again :D


OMGL33TH4X0ROMGL33TH4X0R

Rated 5 / 5 stars

Amazing

Great quality, great work! You did fantastic! :D 5/5, 10/10


People find this review helpful!
rtnario responds:

Thanks, glad you liked it!


CharmanzerCharmanzer

Rated 5 / 5 stars

great drums

y'know what, you don't need permission to remix a song as long as you don't copy parts from the original and claim it as your own work.
good job btw


rtnario responds:

Technically correct when it comes to the license music is released under in the NG Audio Portal. However, asking permission is a sign of respect to the creator. ^^ Thanks!


Shadow3352Shadow3352

Rated 5 / 5 stars

Oh. My. God.

I didn't think I'd come to see a hardcore remix of Gokuisan's Guitar v. Piano... I stand corrected.. and blown away by the talent.


People find this review helpful!
rtnario responds:

Well, here it is! XD Thank you for the review.


LightKeeperLightKeeper

Rated 4.5 / 5 stars

Amazing

I always loved the original but it was always way too simulated for my tastes so I never could quite enjoy it and appreciate as much as I do now. There must have been some tremendous effort put into making this. My only complaint really is that the piano is a bit on the quiet side, especially when it starts soloing. I know you might be trying to keep a balance and blend but it does seem like it could be turned up a bit, at least during the solo and then you could always turn it down a bit.


rtnario responds:

True. But it's really hard to keep the balance if there are like, five guitars already and just one piano XD The tremendous effort was all concentrated on the rhythm guitar and drums, actually. Naturally, I'd like the effort to be heard, but I guess I chose it over the volume of the piano. Oh well XD Thanks for the review!