Score: 9
"Creepy XD"
date: November 5, 2009
It'd definitely do perfect as BG music to a haunted house part in a video game. Wish I knew Flash; I'd definitely use this if I wanted to go for something spooky :(. Anyway, good job overall, I enjoyed it!
Melodies are very nice, especially the ones with the piano. They gave that tension that's always needed in a haunted house game. I liked the part at 1:36, it was well done, and then when all of the melodies started playing together, it was fantastic. That sort of spooky harpsichord (?) sound in the background had some very cool melodies as well, and served as excellent acompaniment to this song.
The instruments were great, including that harpsichord, and the strings added a lot of depth to the song. Piano was OK quality. What could be a nice addition over here is the use of an organ; I'd love to hear a fast paced organ solo somewhere towards the middle, or close to the end of the song. I'm not sure if you used choir voices in here or not (I'm deaf from one ear so I can never be sure :'[ ), but if you didn't, then you should add some, since they always sound well with scary songs. If you did, then, excellent job, just turn 'em up a little ^^.
What I think would be cool is if you added some sound effects to the song. A lot of large soundfonts come with spooky sound effects like heart beats, screams, doors creaking/shutting, etc. (you can PM me if you want any). Maybe you could try and make a beat out of those sound effects to accompany the main melody :P. OK, so that's just a crazy experiment and chances are it'll come out horribly :\, but still, try and add a few sound effects here and there.
Transitions fit perfectly with the feel you were going for in this song. They were all relatively smooth, without anything feeling too sudden. Sometimes, new instruments were introduced rather suddenly, namely the piano, but that was probably intentional, since it sounds better in the song like that than with a smooth transition. Structure was all over the place, which is what made this song so unique, creepy and awesome. Variety here was perfect too; the song never got boring.
Lol, the first part reminds me a little of the Undertaker's entrance theme :P. Well, it was definitely a good intro, and the strings smoothly fading in were a nice touch. As a loop though, it wasn't that impressive. It's a little awkward to make good intro's with loops, because with loops, intro's usually start immediately with the main melody without any gradual progressions, and since you have such a good intro, I think this would be better off as a full song. Either that, or you try and end it as you started it, with a bell every 4 beats. Make it slowly fade down to just the bell at the end, and you should have a smooth loop.
I really liked your use of the bell, it was creative and gave a 'graveyard' feel to the song, if you get what I mean. I think it could use a little more reverb to it, you know, giving it that booming feel. Also, apart from the bell, there was no noticeable percussion. You could add some delayed and reverbed reverse cymbals and maybe a few heavily reverbed kicks. Shakers do wonders in songs like these too. Or you could try my crazy idea of making a beat out of sound effects XP.
As I said before, this'd make a superb background soundtrack to a haunted house. Needs a bit of work regarding the lack of percussion, rough loop, and lack of sound effects, but this is still a really good song. Keep up the great work!
9/10
5/5
-Review Request Club-
November 5, 2009
Author's Response:
First off let me give you some specks on this song to give you an idea of just how crazy I am in how its composed xD
The entire song is in 32/4 at 100 tempo. BUT not only that and most all of the song is in triplets, all except for the "Bell" part and the parts where the strings get a "Solo". Don't ask me why, It just my brain seems to function better when dealing with triplets, and obviously it seems to be working out for me.
The "Harpsichord" part you heard was actually supposed to be acoustic guitar, but but would seem even though they probably failed at sounding like it, they still sounded cool.
The bells are done on the down beats, but each of the bells note lengths are 8 beats long. Lol again my crazy ass just loves doing stuff like that.
And because it's in 32/4 time it gave me far more freedom to do what I wanted, but I made sure i didn't go too crazy with it.
Thanks for the review, I'll try to add some sort of percussion part to it, though i don't know if I come up with something, if i should just submit it separately. Eh i'll figure it out eventually, again thanks! =3