Score: 9

"I can't believe it!"

by: Pibborn

date: August 19, 2008

Holy shit your voice is sooooo Thom Yorkish, LOL! I hope you know it and you don't sing like this everytime. I would be soooo jealous! Really!

Ok, fan boy mode off.

The song is good. It's slower than the original one, which is a really good thing, but... the distortion of the main (kickass) riff is a little too dirty... and it plays only on the left side (I'm using earphones so I can tell). I would fix this two things.
Now, your voice, from a non-fanboyish point of view, is quite good, I would raccomend improving your falsetto, since it's not so powerful as it should be. If you are playing my favourite game ("Let's see who can do the most Thom Yorke-ish voice) then just ignore this last one.

9/10. Keep up the good work!

Score: 7

"Good, but not the best thing since sliced bread"

by: bigdoodsRoCk2743

date: July 6, 2008

I wholeheartedly agree with Madferit. The distorted electric guitar didn't sit well with the song. I would suggest downplaying the guitar a bit, put on a Wah-Wah effect for it, and then plug in some gentle strings at around :20. Also, that one instrument that comes in at around :10, and a lower version of it later in the song: what is it? I've heard it before but I cant place a name. The reason I mention this is because I believe you should put emphasize on them, because I liked em in the song. It gave it a bluesy feel, which is just perfect. Your voice is good, but I will respectfully advise you to keep practicing. A good cover, but (and I say this with no hostility or disrespect whatsoever), it needs work.

Score: 10

"Awesome cover!"

by: ericdrebin

date: March 27, 2008

I like this better than the original. I especially like how the electric contrasts with the acoustic. I really like the voice, too. Kinda reminded me of Nick Drake.

Score: 8

"Pretty good."

by: Madferit

date: June 29, 2007

A little too Thom Yorkish on the vox :D, but you have a nice voice. WAYYYYY too much distortion on the electric guitar, listen to the original for an example on how much less there is. Over all very nice job. But the distorted guitar wrecked the whole serene and beautiful job you did on the rest of it. Also rough falsetto on the second verse, you can actually do one though, which is good. Keep it up though!

Score: 9

"Amazing"

by: the-crunt

date: February 19, 2007

I noticed the slight changes and was like....WTF? but then slowly got used to your style...personally, I think I prefer this to the original!