Score: 8
"Not bad. :)"
date: July 6, 2008
First off, if you're having a hard time mixing because of CPU usage, a slower way (but better in a few senses) is to export a full-quality (192 kbps) MP3, "blindly" change volumes or EQ based on the sound of the MP3, and export again until it sounds good. That's what I did with my PoE remix. ;D
Drums sound nice - really nice, actually, I don't recognize a thing. :O The phased-sounding effect makes the song a bit annoying to listen to, but it's no big deal at all - perhaps turning down the mix knob might have helped. :P Of course, if that whole thing's just one raw loop, I'd be pretty disappointed in you. >:( Most of my typical criticisms for drums don't apply here, they sound pretty well-chosen and well mixed.
Your bass sounds ok, but it's really quiet. I'd recommend turning it up a bit, or EQing it, so it's more present. As is I can barely hear it. D:
Your other synths play now and then (like in Midway, I believe), but for the most part aren't there, giving the song an empty feel. They sound great, but they're just not there enough. I'd recommend another consistent synth on top of the bass, while the other synths keep doing what they're doing, which is really original - you're developing your own style really quickly here. :D I can't tell if they're presets or not, but if they are... >:( If they're not, though, great job.
The transition into the breakdown sounds kinda sudden - ok, you built up, but there's the kick/crash hit and the song drops to zero volume. That pad you fade in later on? Try fading it from a bit higher than zero, just so the song isn't empty for those few seconds there. ;) Your next synth is ok, I heard some crackling as it came in (turn down resonance/Q?) but it fits well enough. Perhaps you might have wanted to EQ it some for some extra presence?
Breaks are nice, the snare sounds quiet to me and the kick sounds loud to me. :\
Your buildup seems short, with little effort. I'd have made it a bit more dramatic than that, considering it's the main buildup of the song. ;D
The peak is nice. What I'd work on at this point is an overall presence and richness of sound - filling the frequencies, basically. Right now, your song feels really thin and empty-sounding compared to the typical song you'd hear on TranceFM. Perhaps you should choose your filler synths better - they're almost all playing in the treble ranges, after all.
Outro is nice, pretty standard. No comments here, though it would have been nice for you to spice it up (and the transitions all around) perhaps with some more creative drum transitions for extra listening pleasure. ;D
You're getting there. ;) Keep it up.
July 6, 2008
Author's Response:
All the melody synths were made by me in 3x 0sc :P The bwaah bass sound you hear in the beginning was a preset from v-station i beleive, i just added some EQ and reverb/delay in it.
I cant really hear any distortion with the frequencies on the synths, may be just your speakers? In the melody synths with the filter going on in the breakdown I do twitch a little bit with the treble EQing but i didn't really noticed that that much. In midway there was, partially from the treble EQing.
Thanks for the review ;P