I quite like both

well bot are charming in their own way but i prefer the old one

I think the old one is better. Mainly because of the girl's face.
And there is something nice about the way it's line is rough.

i wish some one would suprise me like this,

Although I prefer the new one overall because:

-more complete
-better facial expressions
-neater line work
-smoother shading
-things being more stylized to fit the style better (like the box, boobs and bows)
-much better hands


I do like the old one better in some aspects such as:

-I think the hair style on the girl looks better in the older one
-although the line work isn't as neat it is softer on the eye
-her left arm looks in a more natural position